ISSN (Print) - 0012-9976 | ISSN (Online) - 2349-8846

A+| A| A-

A Rejoinder to a Review


A Rejoinder to a Review


armila Bose’s review ‘Bangladesh: Troubled Future’ (March 4, 2006) of my book, Bangladesh: The Next Afghanistan? is tendentious, uses methods that are less than admirable and misrepresents its main thrust.


A Rejoinder to a Review

armila Bose’s review ‘Bangladesh: Troubled Future’ (March 4, 2006) of my book, Bangladesh: The Next Afghanistan? is tendentious, uses methods that are less than admirable and misrepresents its main thrust.

She writes in the very first paragraph, “If the title was meant to attract attention, the author has been pipped to the post by a Bangladeshi writer who recently wrote a book posing the question, ‘Is Bangladesh becoming a Taliban state?’”.

By beginning her sentence with an “if”, she has hinted at the possibility of my having chosen the title of the book to attract attention, without accusing me directly of doing so. In which case, she should have mentioned the name of the author and the title of the book she has in mind, which would have enabled people to assess whether the hint was tenable. Significantly, she has not done so. The question is fully warranted, since Bose linked the title of my book to a possible quest on my part for attracting attention.

The reviewer writes in the second paragraph that I could have dispensed with much of the first chapter – more about this later – and goes on to state, “When he returns to the topic that is of relevance to the main focus of the book, the creation of Bangladesh, he is unfortunately dependent on one or two sources of doubtful reliability and ends up repeating a number of well-worn myths and clichés without addressing the interesting questions thrown up by some of his remarks”.

One of my major sources has been Shahriar Kabir and his publication, Ekattorer Ghatak o Dalara: Ke Kothaye? (The Killers and Agents of Seventy-One: Who and Where Are They?) published by Muktijuddher Chetana Bikash Kendra, Dhaka (Centre for Spreading the Consciousness of the Liberation War), 2nd edition, 1987. I have also referred to Badruddin Umar’s book The Emergence of Bangladesh: Class Struggles in East Pakistan (1947-58), Oxford University Press, Karachi, 2004. Shahriar Kabir is a noted writer, journalist, freedom fighter, and human rights activist, who has been twice jailed and brutally tortured by Begum Khaleda Zia’s regime on patently false charges. Umar is a highly respected historian who requires no introduction.

Besides, my reference to Bangladesh’s “creation” – “liberation” is the word that freedom fighters use – is relevant to the “main focus of the book” only to the extent it shows the collaborationist and murderous role that parties like the Jamaat-e-Islami Bangladesh (JeIB) and its students wing Islami Chhatra Shangha (reincarnated in 1978 as the Islami Chhatra Shibir), played during the liberation struggle, and explains the circumstances leading to East Pakistan’s (now Bangladesh) alienation from West Pakistan. This is because the JeIB is an important constituent of the coalition government that until recently ruled Bangladesh with the leader of the Bangladesh Nationalist Party, Khaleda Zia, as prime minister.

The fact is that the JeIB is the fountainhead of Islamist terrorism in Bangladesh today. All the three important terrorist leaders who have been arrested since October last year – Banglabhai aka Siddiqul Islam, the operations commander of the Jagrata Muslim Janata Bangladesh, Abdur Rahman, the Shaekh (spiritual leader) of Jamaatul Mujaheedin Bangladesh and Mufti Hannan, operations commander of the

(Continued on p 4828)




Six One Two Three months year years years

Institutions – 1250 2300 3300 Individuals 500 935 1750 2500

Concessional Rates

Teachers/Researchers – 685 – 1800 Students – 450 – –

Concessional rates are available only in India. To avail of concessional rates, certificate from relevant institution is essential. Remittance by money order/bank draft preferred. Please add Rs 35 to outstation cheques towards bank collection charges.

Nepal and Bhutan

Institutions – 1500 – 4150 Individuals – 1250 – 3500


(US $)

Air Mail Surface Mail


1yr 2yrs 3yrs 1yr 2yrs 3yrs Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Bangladesh 80 150 200 65 120 175 Other countries 150 275 375 90 170 240

Individuals Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Bangladesh 50 90 125 30 50 75 Other countries 100 175 240 65 120 170

All remittances to:

Economic and Political Weekly

Economic and Political Weekly

Hitkari House, 284 Shahid Bhagatsingh Road, Mumbai 400 001 Phones: 2269 6072/73 Fax: (022) 2269 6072 Editor (December 1969-January 2004) : Krishna Raj

Editor : C Rammanohar Reddy

Deputy Editor : Bernard D’Mello

Senior Assistant Editors : Anuradha Kumar, Lina Mathias, Sheba Tejani, Bharati Bhargava (Delhi)

Editorial Staff : Prabha Pillai

Editorial Assistant : P S Leela

Editorial Consultant : Gautam Navlakha (Delhi)

Circulation : Gauraang Pradhan (Manager), B S Sharma

Advertisement Manager : Kamal G Fanibanda

General Manager and Publisher : K Vijayakumar

EPW Research Foundation

C 212, Akurli Industrial Estate, Kandivali (East) Mumbai 400 101, Phones: 2887 3038/3041 Fax: (022) 2887 3038.

Director : S L Shetty

Economic and Political Weekly November 18, 2006


(Continued from p 4710)

Harkat-ul-Jihad-al-Islami Bangladesh – are alumni either of the JeIB or the Islami Chhatra Shibir or both.

Again, Sharmila Bose writes in the penultimate paragraph, “The trouble is that though the book appears to be heavily documented, the notes reveal it to be almost entirely reliant on one newspaper of Bangladesh and of its internet edition”. The newspaper, whose name she did not mention, is The Daily Star, perhaps the most respected publication of its kind in Bangladesh. Faulting one for relying on its internet edition as a source of news and comment regarding Bangladesh, would be like blaming one for using the internet edition of The New York Times or The Washington Post for writing a book on the US. Also, had she looked at the endnotes carefully, she would have found references to material that had appeared in Bengalilanguage newspapers like Prothom Alo and Janakantha and Englishlanguage newspapers like The Independent and The Bangladesh Observer. What matters is not the number of sources one has consulted but the correctness or otherwise of the information and comments cited. Significantly, Bose has not controverted a single information or editorial observation I have cited from The Daily Star.

Finally, the reviewer has written, “The interpretations of Islam and the historical rise of ‘fundamentalist’ Islam are indeed important issues, but this book is not the place and Karlekar probably is not the best person to address them”. If she had read the first chapter carefully, she would have noticed that a considerable part of it deals with the rise of fundamentalist Islam in what is now Bangladesh, a process that began in the last quarter of the 18th century. This is important for understanding the nature, strength and permanence of the constituency that the JeIB and the ICS appeal to.


New Delhi

Notes for Contributors

Here are some guidelines fortake up to six to eight months from the address, day-time phone numbers andauthors who wish to make date of acceptance to appear in the email address. submissions to the journal. EPW. Every effort will, however, be made (The email address of writers in the Special

to ensure early publication. Papers with Article, Commentary and Discussion

Special Articles

immediate relevance for policy would be sections will be published at the end ofEPW welcomes original research papers considered for early publication. Please the article.)

in any of the social sciences.

note that this is a matter of editorial * Authors are requested to prepare their

* Articles must be no more than 8,000

judgment. soft copy versions in text formats. PDF

words, including notes, references

versions are not accepted by the EPW.

and tables. Longer articles will not be Commentaries

Authors are encouraged to use UK Englishprocessed. EPW invites short contributions to the spellings (Writers using MS Word or

  • * Contributions should be sent in a hard ‘Commentary’ section on topical social, similar software could change thecopy format accompanied by a floppy/ economic and political developments. These appropriate settings in the LanguageCD version. A soft copy can also be should ideally be between 1,000 and 2,500 menu of the application).sent by email. Hard and soft copy words and exclusive to the EPW. * Contributors are requested to send articlesversions of articles are essential for Short contributions may be sent by email. that are complete in all respects, includingprocessing. references, as this facilitates quicker
  • * Special articles should be Book Reviews processing. accompanied by an abstract of a EPW sends out books for review. It does * When there are major developments in
  • maximum of 150-200 words. not normally accept unsolicited reviews. the field of study after the first submission,
  • * Papers should not have been However, all reviews that are received are authors can send a revised version. simultaneously submitted for publication read with interest and where a book has not EPW requests writers not to send to another journal or newspaper. If the been sent out for review, the unsolicited review revised versions based on stylistic paper has appeared earlier in a different is on occasion considered for publication. changes/additions, deletions of version, we would appreciate a copy of references, minor changes, etc, as this
  • Letters

    this along with the submitted paper. poses challenges in processing.

    Readers of EPW are encouraged to send comments and suggestions (300-400 words)

    * Graphs and charts prepared in MS * All submissions will be acknowledged

    Office (Word/Excel) or equivalent software immediately on receipt with a reference

    on published articles to the Letters column.

    are preferable to material prepared in number. Quoting the reference number

    All letters should have the writer’s full name in inquiries will help.

    jpeg or other formats.

    and postal address. * EPW posts all published articles on its web site and may reproduce them on CDs.

    * Every effort is taken to complete early

    processing of the papers we receive.


    Since we receive more than 35 articles Address for communication:

    EPW encourages researchers to comment

    every week and adequate time has to be Economic and Political Weekly,

    on Special Articles. Submissions should be

    provided for internal reading and external Hitkari House,

    1,000 to 2,000 words.

    refereeing. It can take up to four 284 Shahid Bhagatsingh Road, months for a final decision on whether General Guidelines Mumbai 400 001, India. the paper is accepted for publication. * Writers are requested to provide full Email:,

    * Articles accepted for publication can details for correspondence: postal

    Economic and Political Weekly November 18, 2006

    Dear Reader,

    To continue reading, become a subscriber.

    Explore our attractive subscription offers.

    Click here

    Back to Top